Commentary..63rd Commonwealth Contest

by  Harold Owen, G2HLU.

  A place in the sun,  in the Caribbean, or failing that the Mediterranean, again seemed to offer a good 
chance of success.  That said there were eight different Commonwealth countries and ten different call 
areas in the top ten stations this year. Top place in the Open section, and the Senior Rosebowl, goes to 
Bruce Sawyer, ZF2NT, followed by George Beasley, 5B4AGC (third in 1999 and winner of the 
Restricted section in 1998), with John Sluymer, VE3EJ (winner in 1998, for the latest of several 
occasions), a very short distance behind.  Bob Whelan, G3PJT, as VP5C made it to fourth place, and 
Andy Chadwick, 9G5VJ, had to settle for fifth: Andy did not prosper as well in Ghana as he did in Malta 
in 1999 (winner) and 1998 (second), though he came third in 1997 when operating from 9G. Barry, 
VK2BJ, turned in a VK record score despite poor conditions and has been awarded this year’s 
Commonwealth medal for this and consistent top class entries for many years.
The Col. Thomas Rose Bowl goes to Jan Fisher, G0IVZ, in thirteenth place, this time.  Dave Lawley, 
G4BUO, sacrificed his chance of the award for an umpteenth time by operating his station as GB5CC, 
with G4TSH.
Top place in the Restricted section is again filled by Bill Metcalfe, VE6BF, operating VE6JY, who is 
awarded the Junior Rosebowl; Bob Nash, VE3KZ (fourth in the Open section in 1999) is second, and 
Steve Ireland, VK6VZ, usually found in the Open section, was compelled by other commitments to 
enter the Restricted section, where he put in an excellent log to reach third place.
We had a record number - eight - of HQ stations.  Thanks to them all.  Despite uncertainty about 
5Z4WI and VK5XE they have been scored as HQ in all contacts - not that it made much difference, 
since there were no other 5Z4s and VK5s were not thick on the ground!  VP6BR, on Pitcairn Island, 
was a new bonus for many entrants. ZS0E has been given separate call area status. 
Comments about conditions varied, but entrants were unanimous in deploring poor propagation on 80 
metres, and nearly all were disappointed with 10 metres; only ZL1MH and ZL2CD had good words to 
say about that band.  Despite the record number of QSOs made by the top three stations in 1999, the 
total number of QSOs made by the top ten stations in 1999 (6740), was appreciably lower than the 
corresponding figure of 8150 in 2000.  This must mean something!  There were again several first-time 
entrants, who enjoyed themselves and promised to be back.  Many entrants commented on their 
appreciation of the unique character of this contest .
The year 2000 brought the largest total entry of recent years, 138, excluding the record number for the 
60th Anniversary Contest in 1997.  Compared with last year there was a small decrease in numbers for 
the Open section and a small increase for the Restricted.
VK3MR's comments last year about it being probably his last BERU were unhappily prophetic: we have 
now lost another of our stalwarts.  Many will remember his outstanding DX performance of years past 
when he 'covered the world with rhombics'.

PARTICIPATION  
The total number of callsigns recorded was up this year, to 791 over all bands (498 G, 155 VE, 51 VK, 
32 ZL, 10 ZS).  Some of the rarer prefixes were as usual available only in certain parts of the world, 
except for the most well-equipped stations, and - again as usual - some participants only made a few 
contacts.  Call areas were up again, to 60:  3B8, 4S, 5B, 5H, 5Z (HQ), 9G, 9H, 9J, 9M2, 9Y, AP, AX2 
(HQ), G (including GI, GM, GU, GW, M, MM), GB (HQ), J6, P2, P2 (HQ), S2, T32, V3, V4, VE1-9, 
VE1 (HQ), VE2 (HQ), VE5 (HQ), VK1-8, VK4 (HQ), VK5 (HQ), VO1, VP5-6, VP9, VQ9, VU, Z2, 
ZC4, ZF, ZL1-4, ZL6, ZS0, ZS1, ZS6.
Participation by bands was:  80m, 182 stations including 97 Gs, 39 call areas; 40m, 348 (207 Gs), 48;  
20m 573 (356 Gs), 50;  15m 506 (334 Gs), 47;  10m 418 (303 Gs), 47.  The LF bands showed little 
change from 1999, but figures are up for 20m and 15m (totals and Gs), and the totals for 10m are 
surprisingly a little higher than in 1999, despite the much poorer conditions.

LOGS  
Paper logs were in the majority (55%), though the proportion of logs sent by e-mail increased again, to 
35%, and 13% were sent on disk (total exceeds 100% because a few used two formats).  All are 
transferred to paper for checking. We had a problem with some e mail logs being received incomplete. 
This resulted in two stations being unplaced as it was not possible to score their logs. 
Grateful thanks are due to those entrants who provided dupe sheets (and bonus lists), especially to such 
as 9J2BO and ZB2EO, with large logs, who put callsigns in alphanumeric order without benefit of 
computer (and ZB2EO's entry, as ever, a model of neatness and clarity).  Regrettably, much time was 
expended by the adjudicator in making dupe sheets for those many logs which did not provide them.  
Eleven unmarked duplicates were found  - one station had three, at 55 penalty points each!  All would  
have been avoided if the entrants had kept dupe sheets - verb.  sap.!  Only 29% provided a Band/Call 
Areas total, so that too had  to be calculated for the majority.  Eighty-four entrants qualified  for the 
special certificate, by working 63 or more Band/Call areas (64 will be required in 2001.)
It is pleasing to record that in a number of logs no error was detected:  VO1GO had the highest-scoring 
'perfect' log in the Open section, GM3POI in the Restricted section (for the second year running).  There 
was also a fair number of entries which lost only 2 or 4 points, through a single digit error in one or two 
exchanges. 

SOAPBOX
‘ Not yet mastered bonus gathering’, 5B4AGC. ‘ I worked more VK stations over the weekend than in 
the last 5 years … fantastic contest for DX’, G0VQR. ‘ Have the gods got something against us: 
reasonable conditions in the week, then the dreaded aurora strikes’, G3HZL. ‘ Best ever score’, VE2ZP. 
‘ Serious snow static on Saturday night’, VE3EJ. ‘Restricted section is a terrific idea for overworked 
dads like myself’, VK6VZ. ‘Band (15) swarming with low level Gs half an hour before close..’, 
VK8HA. ‘ Plagued by storms and five power cuts’, 9J2BO, and ‘ we did not have power supply the 
whole of Sunday…’, VU2UR. ‘A big hats-off to all the VEs, from me’, ZL1MH, and so say all of the 
rest of us !

NEXT YEAR
The next Commonwealth Contest will be from 10th to 11th March, 2001. 
A number of stations have requested changes of time to allow an earlier finish in VK/ZL but no change 
will be made at present. Minor corrections to the call area list, ZD9, Tristan da Cunha, and ZS0 for 
South Africa, will be made. You will require 64 band call areas for a certificate.
Some have asked for a multi-op section and in effect we already have this in the HQ stations table. Why 
not enter a HQ station from your call area ?
It is becoming easier to mount contest DXpeditions these days. So why not activate some of the more 
unusual Commonwealth call areas around the contest weekend ? It can be a lot of fun and you can get 
pretty high up the table. Many parts of the Commonwealth are rather sunny and a good break from the 
northern winters.

Here are the FINAL scores for BERU 2000.

Thanks to the adjudicator, Harold, G2HLU, and the RSGB HF Contest Committee.

Click here to go to the write up

>Restricted Section >HQ Stations > Country Placings


Open Section

Posn     Call     80     40     20     15     10     Total     QSOs	BCAs     
1*+	ZF2NT	836	1658	2873	2375	1668	9410	1003
		72/24	164/43	317/65	264/53	186/37			134
2*	5B4AGC	683	1397	2755	2228	1808	8871	1001
		65/18	141/35	301/63	264/45	230/33			121
3*	VE3EJ	914	2070	2575	2178	1096	8833	837
		72/28	204/53	253/66	236/50	72/37			146
4*	VP5C	637	1582	2245	2263	1883	8610	883
		54/19	167/39	235/55	221/58	206/43			122
5*	9G5VJ	200	984	2504	2510	2373	8571	929
		8/8	102/24	246/64	274/57	299/44			120
6*	VE2ZP	909	1657	2360	1923	1018	7867	730
		74/28	157/44	228/62	221/41	48/39			133
7*	9H1ZA	711	1338	1949	1963	1541	7502	879
		76/17	148/31	216/44	221/43	217/23			110
8*	VE7CC	508	1126	2228	2209	1379	7450	601
		22/20	57/42	200/62	231/53	90/47			126
9*	VK2BJ	705	1303	2489	1595	1030	7122	566
		29/28	89/43	255/61	143/44	50/39			132
10*   G3XTT/VP9	808	1429	2098	1433	1050	6818	721
		81/21	147/35	224/49	139/37	130/20			101
11*	ZL6QH	768	1363	2146	1616	843	6736	565
		43/28	108/42	214/54	151/44	49/30			106
12*	VK4EMM	678	1235	2181	1658	973	6725	543
		28/27	101/37	215/57	144/47	55/35			121
13*++	G0IVZ	440	1285	1909	1814	779	6227	343
		24/16	67/48	113/68	106/65	33/31			142
14	VE3QAA	344	1416	1917	1386	618	5681	563
		27/11	158/33	202/47	148/33	28/24			98
15	G3OZF	438	1158	1794	1481	721	5592	279
		21/17	60/43	92/67	73/56	33/28			137
16*	ZL1MH	551	960	1711	1110	910	5242	357
		23/22	60/33	161/51	58/41	545/32			110
17*	ZB2EO	155	680	1991	1093	1041	4960	597
		11/5	81/14	232/42	144/19	129/20			67
18	VE3VHB	513	785	1663	1058	845	4864	342
		35/17	49/27	133/50	84/32	41/32			100
19	G3TBK	401	757	1584	1435	655	4832	247
		17/16	38/29	86/58	79/52	27/26			119
20*	9J2BO	25	405	1279	1405	1490	4604	484
		1/1	26/14	106/38	157/31	194/26			76
21*	VO1GO	555	1080	1390	1115	345	4485	409
		47/16	104/28	130/37	107/29	21/12			79
22	VE3XN	453	645	1675	961	549	4283	335
		19/18	29/25	152/46	112/21	23/21			83
23	VE2AYU	240	1130	1569	1063	175	4177	447
		17/8	124/26	166/38	133/20	7/7			68
24	G3IAF	355	808	1345	1218	400	4126	191	
		15/114	39/31	61/52	60/46	16/16			111
25*	ZM2AZ	621	1061	912	965	535	4094	261
		25/25	82/33	70/29	567/34	27/20			94
26	G2QT	348	734	1335	1079	565	4061	210
		15/114	36/28	71/49	61/40	27/22			107
27	G0WAT 	318	806	1526	1128	248	4026	222
		16/12	46/29	88/55	62/41	10/10			96
28	G3GLL	348	778	1200	1150	500	3976	184
		14/14	32/31	60/45	58/43	20/20			106
29	GW3HGJ	371	820	1280	888	325	3684	174
		15/15	36/32	68/47	42/34	13/13			96
30	VA2FB	-	1018	1045	835	598	3496	285
		-	84/30	91/30	80/22	30/23			71
31	G2HLU	223	665	1205	1058	323	3474	160
		9/9	29/26	57/46	52/40	13/13			92
32	VE7JKZ	50	865	835	1110	485	3345	185
		2/2	41/33	39/32	82/35	21/19			80
33	VE7VF	25	474	875	1235	575	3184	246
		1/1	20/29	57/30	125/31	43/18			69
34	G4CZB	355	495	995	900	325	3070	142
		15/114	23/19	47/38	44/34	13/13			80
35	G3LIK	298	375	1143	895	348	3059	139
		12/12	15/15	54/44	43/34	14/14			85
36*	VE1AYY	285	815	968	783	182	3033	310
		23/9	77/23	96/26	104/17	10/7			61	
37	G4IIY	225	693	853	963	175	2909	147
		9/9	35/26	43/32	53/35	7/7			78
38*	VE4IM	195	528	1150	621	221	2715	141 
		11/7	26/20	66/41	29/24	9/9			68
39	G3EBH	25	421	1050	808	398	2702	122
		1/1	17/17	50/40	38/31	16/16			76
40	VK6HQ	146	685	1556	300	-	2687	201
		7/6	34/26	248/42	12/12	-			55
41	G3KKP	150	475	915	698	423	2661	117
		6/6	19/19	43/35	32/27	17/17			77
42	G2VJ	223	480	884	713	250	2550	112
		10/9	20/19	38/25	34/30	10/10			79
43	G3GPE	221	425	884	771	223	2524	113
		10/9	17/17	43/34	35/30	9/9			74
44	G3IGW	125	679	555	918	225	2502	122
		5/5	32/29	29/24	47/37	9/9			79
45	G3DEF	223	453	730	774	298	2478	111
		9/9	19/18	35/28	36/39	12/12			70
46	G5MY	248	556	924	568	171	2467	116
		10/10	29/21	43/36	27/22	7/7			71
47	VE1LS	296	603	668	628	250	2445	135
		12/12	37/21	38/24	38/22	10/10			68
48	G3JJG	75	596	613	875	223	2382	111
		3/3	24/24	35/22	40/34	9/9			77
49	G3VDL	198	460	763	705	198	2324	102
		8/8	20/28	33/30	33/27	8/8			72
50	G3MPB	25	605	743	808	125	2306	103
		1/1	25/24	34/29	38/3`1	5/5			67
51*	VK5GZ	275	346	1238	360	75	2294	145
		11/11	14/14	97/38	20/13	3/3			52
52	G3JKY	98	296	725	788	325	2232	100
		4/4	12/12	33/28	38/30	13/13			68
53=*	VK3ZC	271	498	923	440	75	2207	103
		11/11	20/20	49/34	20/27	3/3			54
53=	G3TEV	50	425	680	877	175	2207	98
		2/2	19/17	29/27	41/34	7/7			66
55	G3ICH	-	321	991	434	175	1921	88
		-	1113/13	47/38	20/17	8/7			57
56	VK2DID	-	498	673	583	100	1854	98
		-	24/20	44/23	26/23	4/4			51
57	G3BPM	221	473	467	551	125	1837	83
		9/9	20/19	22/21	27/22	5/5			56
58	VE1EP	246	400	546	450	150	1792	72
		10/10	16/16	22/22	18/18	6/6			66
59	G4IDL	23	223	592	614	244	1696	69
		1/1	9/9	34/24	25/25	10/10			54
60	G3NAN	-	246	593	611	225	1675	77
		-	10/10	27/23	31/23	9/9			53
61	ZL1HV	75	150	710	577	100	1612	76
		3/3	6/6	34/27	29/22	4/4			40
62	G3HKO	75	325	530	450	125	1505	70
		3/3	13/13	27/20	22/20	5/5			48
63	VE1KB	148	123	613	230	75	1189	79
		8/6	6/5	46/20	16/8	3/3			37
64	G3ZDD	-	239	519	317	71	1146	57
		-	11/10	29/21	14/13	3/3			39
65	GM3PPE	-	-	1101	-	-	1101	49
		-	-	49/43	-	-			26
66	VK3KS	50	323	394	-	-	767	31
		2/2	13/13	16/16	-	-			23
67	G0VQR	-	-	406	75	150	631	28
		-	-	19/16	3/3	6/6			20
68	VK5HO	125	150	198	25	-	498	20
		5/5	6/6	8/8	1/1	-			16	
69	G3KSK	-	-	-	-	173	173	7
		-	-	-	-	7/7			7
   #	ZL2BR	225	585	1580	1255	805?	4450?	306?
		9/9	33/21	124/48	99/38	41/30?			89?
   #	VE2AWR	-	915	610	1055	275	2855	247
		-	83/25	42/20	111/25	11/11			58


+	Senior Rose Bowl
++	Col. Thomas Rose Bowl
*	Certificate of Merit
#	Claimed scores:  unchecked


Restricted Section

Posn     Call     80     40     20     15     10     Total     QSOs 

1*+++	VE6JY	100	1305	1651	1597	816	5469	430
		4/4	85/45	159/43	142/45	40/31			106
2*	VE3KZ	537	951	1669	1484	650	5291	483
		33/19	79/28	159/45	178/30	34/24			94
3*	VK6VZ	100	828	1916	598	557	3999	428
		4/4	74/23	204/45	69/13	77/9			64
4*	GM0GAV	298	725	1231	1163	573	3990	177
		12/12	34/28	55/48	53/45	23/23			107
5	G3LZQ	400	775	1228	1035	503	3941	183
		16/16	37/30	58/47	51/39	21/20			110
6*	VK2APK	250	1166	1515	510	488	3929	291
		10/10	65/43	1678/35	26/19	22/19			78
7	VE3FU	300	515	1180	980	605	3580	273
		12/123	28/19	108/32	100/24	25/24			81
8*	VE7UZ	150	555	945	1170	730	3550	212
		6/6	24/22	68/31	76/40	38/27			84
9	VE3UOL	192	681	1098	974	453	3398	296
		8/8	45/23	104/29	120/19	19/18			66
10	G3KZR	248	746	933	1100	350	3377	157
		10/10	30/30	43/36	60/40	14/14			88
11	G3LET	-	505	1430	860	419	3214	152
		-	21/20	70/54	44/32	17/17			84
12	G3LHJ	175	628	938	913	505	3159	161
		7/7	30/24	48/35	55/32	21/20			85
13	G3JYP	246	585	982	912	394	3119	141
		10/10	25/23	46/38	44/35	16/16			91
14	G4AZN	173	398	1120	1000	425	3116	144
		7/7	16/16	52/43	53/27	17/17			84
15	G0ORH	-	451	1235	821	473	2980	153
		-	21/18	67/46	46/30	19/19			80
16*	ZL2CD	326	592	754	880	397	2949	191
		14/13	35/22	51/27	74/27	16/16			64
17*	VK4TT	-	425	983	818	533	2759	147
		-	17/17	45/38	60/26	25/21			65	
18	VA3UZ	-	790	876	558	521	2745	155
		-	50/27	48/32	36/19	21/21			70
19	G2AFV	175	698	1023	645	175	2716	124
		7/7	32/27	45/40	33/24	7/7			77
20	GW3NJW	150	533	875	725	325	2608	120
		6/6	23/21	43/33	35/28	13/13			77
21*	ZL1PC	55	749	754	725	204	2587	132
		7/6	40/29	43/28	33/28	9/9			70
22	G3VYI	125	604	1080	615	150	2574	119
		5/5	26/24	49/42	31/23	6/6			70
23	G3YEC	90	495	1315	450	223	2573	60
		2/2	11/11	32/29	10/10	5/5			47
24*	VK8HA	-	153	1051	773	486	2463	151
		-	7/6	5938	59/24	26/18			61
25*	VE5SF	25	298	835	1003	296	2457	181
		1/1	16/11	75/23	77/31	12/12			49
26	G3RSD	98	380	800	928	225	2431	112
		4/4	16/15	36/31	47/35	9/9			69
27	GM3CFS	-	425	1008	771	175	2379	97
		-	17/17	42/40	31/31	7.7			66
28	VE3STT	200	305	748	630	425	2308	134
		8/8	13/12	42/27	54/18	17/17			60
29	G3KNU	48	325	866	751	275	2265	112
		2/2	13/13	46/33	40/28	11/11			63
30	GM3POI	-	1485	305	150	275	2215	107
		-	77/55	13/12	6/6	11/11			60
31	G3HEJ	100	300	760	741	275	2176	92
		4/4	12/12	32/30	33/29	11/11			64
32	G4CXT	100	335	803	710	200	2148	94
		4/4	15/13	37/31	20/28	8/8			65
33	G3HZL	175	246	971	581	125	2098	90
		7/7	10/10	43/38	25/23	5/5			62
34	VK6AJ	-	171	1429	125	290	2015	173
		-	7/7	131/39	5/5	30/7			44
35	G6QQ	25	355	620	641	300	1941	85
		1/1	15/14	28/24	29/25	12/12			58
36	G3ZGC	225	383	643	375	150	1776	76
		9/9	17/15	29/25	15/15	6/6			59
37*	VU2UR	-	175	978	525	-	1678	112
		-	11/6	76/30	25/20	-			40
38	G3KKQ	250	380	540	250	225	1645	69
		10/10	16/15	24/21	10/10	9/9			54
39	G3GMS	-	175	565	663	225	1628	70
		-	7/7	25/22	29/26	9/9			51
40	VK2BQQ	250	400	500	348	-	1498	64
		10/10	16/16	24/19	14/14	-			45
41	GW3SB	75	223	548	505	100	1451	63
		3/3	9.9	26.21	21/20	4/4			48
42*	VK5GN	25	55	1019	75	80	1254	112
		2/1	3/2	100/27	3/3	4/3			21
43	G0IGP	-	-	430	558	150	1138	48
		-	-	18/17	24/22	6/6			33	
44	G4ZME	-	-	534	323	196	1053	45
		-	-	24/21	13/`13	8/8			35
45	G3GMM	-	25	235	493	125	878	41
		-	1/1	11/9	24/19	5/5			26
46	G4FDC	-	-	200	198	175	573	23
		-	-	8/8	8/8	7/7			23
47	VK4XW	-	-	444	90	-	534	28
		-	-	22/17	6/3	-			11
48	VK8AV	-	-	375	50	25	450	22
		-	-	19/14	2/2	1/1			14
49	VA3XRZ	-	-	398	-	-	398	23
		-	-	-	23/15	-	-		12
50	G4XPE	-	-	210	125	50	385	17
		-	-	10/8	5/5	2/2			14
51	GW4XXF	-	-	-	50	125	175	7	
		-	-	-	2/2	5/5			7

+++	Junior Rose Bowl
*	Certificate of Merit

HQ Stations

Posn     Call     80     40     20     15     10     Total     QSOs         
 1	GB5CC (G4BUO, G4TSH)
		917	1578	2095	1792	1028	7410	688
		93/23	142/44	191/58	166/49	96/28			123

2	VK4WIA (VK4XA)
		225	646	1884	883	913	4551	320
		9/9	30/25	185/54	49/32	47/34			91

3	AX2OOO (VK2AYD)
		175	560	1660	925	600	3920	280
		7/7	28/21	1148/46	73/27	24/24			76

4	VE5RAC (VE5MX)
		50	455	820	1043	806	3174	181
		2/2	19/18	48/29	78/33	34/32			73

5	VE1RAC (VE1JS)
		196	358	514	652	164	1884	168
		8/8	31/11	45/15	77/14	7/7			35

6	VA2RAC (VE2GK)
		95	351	601	335	275	1657	86	
		4/4	16/14	35/22	20/15	11/11			45

7	5Z4WI	120	306	285	-	433	1144	102
		8/4	30/11	21/9	-	43/11			21

8	VK5XE	273	200	300	96	75	944	38 	
		11/11	8/8	12/12	4/4	3/3			32
           

Checklogs from G2CIL, G3SXW, G3TXF, G3WP and G4OGB are gratefully acknowledged.

COUNTRY PLACINGS 


Canada
Open
3 VE3EJ
6 VE2ZP
8 VE7CC
14 VE3QAA
18 VE3VHB
21 VO1GO
22  VE3XN
23 VE2AYU
30 VA2FB
32  VE7JKZ
33 VE7VF
36 VE1AYY
38  VE4IM
47 VE1LS
58 VE1EP
63  VE1KB
# VE2AWR

Restricted
1  VE6JY
2  VE3KZ
7 VE3FU
8 VE7UZ
9 VE3UOL
18  VA3UZ
25  VE5SF
28 VE3STT
49  VA3XRZ

Australia/New Zealand
Open
9  VK2BJ
11  ZL6QH
12  VK4EMM
16  ZL1MH
25  ZM2AZ
40  VK6HQ
51  VK5GZ
53  VK3ZC
52  VK2DID
61  ZL1HV
66 VK3KS
68  VK5KO
#  ZL2BR

Restricted
3  VK6VZ
6  VK2APK
16  ZL2CD
17  VK4TT
21  ZL1PC
24  VK8HA
34  VK6AJ
40  VK2BQQ
42  VK5GN
47  VK4XW
48  VK8AV